[Written by Ric Viers for Designing Sound]
A few months ago, I was watching an episode of Family Guy. Peter Griffin was up to his usual antics and during one of the scenes, he was crushed by a falling piano. BAM! I scratched my head and hit rewind on the DVR. Sure enough, the piano smash they used was a sound effect that I created for a commercial library. It’s always fun to randomly hear your work.
Looking back on when I created that sound, I’m actually a little surprised at how haphazardly I recorded back then. When I first started, I didn’t have very good monitors. In fact, all I had was a pair of high end computer speakers and a good pair of headphones. I recorded on DAT recorders which are extremely noisy compared to today’s low-end handheld recorders. Thankfully, I had really good microphones. I created several libraries for major companies using this set up and grew my studio as the work increased.
The piano crash was a combination of a couple of random keys slammed on a grand piano. The recorder was a Sony TCD-8 Walkman DAT recorder. The microphone was the cheap one that came with the unit. The wood smashes and splinters came out of a recording session on a stage. Those elements were recorded with a MKH-416 on a Sony TCD-10 DAT recorder. I mixed the elements together and designed several effects that ended up in a sound library. Nobody knew how the sounds were recorded. They heard the sounds for what they were. Years later, the sounds I created with my beginner package are still being used by professionals.
The point is you don’t need a million dollar studio to achieve million dollar sound!
Mark Mangini told me a story about how he needed a simple sound at the last minute during a mix session at Todd AO for a major film. I don’t recall exactly what the sound was – a pen being set down or something like that. He giggled and told me he whipped out his Zoom recorder and recorded the sound right there on the mix desk. So, in a facility with millions of dollars worth or recorders, mixers and microphones, he used a recorder that could fit in his pocket.
It’s easy to get hung up on gear. But don’t confuse gear with quality. Techniques will always trump the technology. Always.
Gear is a money pit. It’s a trap. It’s fool’s gold. You can sit and stare at catalogs all day and drool over a certain piece of gear, convincing yourself that if you only had this one piece of gear your sound would be amazing. Then, you save up and buy it. It sounds great. Then, a month later, you see something else in the catalog and convince yourself that if you only had this one more piece of gear…
Stop! Put your hands in the air and step away from the catalog. You’re chasing your tail and you’ll never catch it.
You are an artist. The artist paints the picture, not the brushes. Brushes are important, but a true artist knows that he could use his fingers to create art if he didn’t have brushes. The bottom line: don’t wait for that dream studio before you start your career. Press the red button and get started now!
Record, record, record! Edit, design, mix, rinse and repeat.
The White Album by the Beatles is one of the greatest albums of all time. What’s funny is that for less than $2,000, you can go to Guitar Center and by software, mics and even monitors that would probably surpass the quality of the equipment the Beatles used to record that album. This is unbelievable, but true. Digital technology has leveled the playing field. A laptop rig can produce higher quality recordings than what the Fab Four used to record legendary songs.
Don’t let the size of your mic cabinet determine whether or not you are a professional. Start developing your craft now. As the paying gigs come, you can always upgrade. But, don’t wait for the upgrade to get started.
Here are a few tips to help you achieve that “million dollar” sound.
1. Where you position the mic is far more important than which mic you use. This one should be a no-brainer. Mic placement is everything when it comes to recording. A bad mic in a good place will sound better than a good mic in a bad place. Find the sound source and choose an optimal position to capture that sound. If you aren’t using all of the tracks on your recorder, try experimenting by putting additional mics in different places. You can mix them together or choose your favorite position in the edit. A nice trick, if you are recording in mono is to set up a second mic with a level that’s 6-12dB lower than your primary mic. This will give you a back up track, just in case the first track clips, peaks or if something bumps the stand during the take.
2. Recording with good levels on a cheap recorder will give you better quality than recording with poor levels on a great recorder. Preamps are the most important feature I look for in a recorder. A recorder with poor preamps is nothing more than a high tech paper weight. But even with quality preamps, if your signal is too low you will get noise when you amplify the sound in post. Always record at the hottest level possible. You can always back it down later, but you can’t increase poor levels without introducing noise. Quick side note: If you are recording something that is super quiet, for example a grasshopper shaving his beard, you aren’t going to get ‘great’ levels. Don’t turn the mic preamps too far past unity, or you could introduce system noise. Most nature ambiences are the same way.
3. Spend your money on gear that will make a difference, but save on the things that really don’t. Gold plated, super high-end microphone cables that were manufactured by angels up in heaven will not sound better than a cable that costs a third of the price. You have better things to spend your money on. Don’t fall into the trap that a single cable will increase the quality of your work. Buy good cables so that they will last longer and handle the rigors of the field, not because they were hand crafted by pixies. I’ve put a $60 cable next to a $15 cable and ran tests with no noticeable difference to the ears. Perhaps, if we put them both on scopes we could see unique signatures that would prove that one was better than the other, but the audience won’t do that. Remember, consumers think MP3s sound better than CDs.
4. Where you record is one of the most important ingredients for recording good sound effects. I would rather record in a quiet location with a $2,000 gear package than in a noisy, reverberant location with a $20,000 gear package. Unless you are going for a specific effect, try to record your material dry. You can always add effects later, but you can’t take the effect out once it’s been recorded. That said, if something spontaneous comes up, but the location is not optimal, record anyways. You never know when you’ll hit pay dirt. However, if you’re lining up a location to record footsteps, avoid setting up in a building next door to the airport.
5. Avoid over-processing your sounds. Compressors, equalizers, noise reducers and reverbs are all very useful tools. But, like salt, can spoil the taste if overused. When building your sound libraries, go with the less is more approach. Your goal is to create sound effects that can be tweaked and processed later. If you go too heavy on compression when you master the file, you’ll be stuck with those dynamics. However, if you leave the original dynamics in the file, the file becomes more versatile later. The same goes with reverbs and equalization. There are times when you’ll want to over process and go nuts with creativity. That’s great if you end up there. But, if you start there with a processed file, you’ll have nowhere else to go.
6. Monitor at consistent levels. Switching back and forth between loud and soft levels can be deceptive to your ears and lead to poor decision making. This is true for headphones and for studio monitors. Find that happy spot where it sounds “just right” and stay there. Don’t touch that dial! Occasionally, you’ll need to crank up your levels to check for noise or other background problems, but be sure to return the knob to the same level. If not, you’ll end up with weird and inconsistent levels in your mixes throughout the day. Never work at levels that leave your ears sore at the end of the day. When in doubt, work at a lower level and stay there.
7. Your creativity. If you’re not a song writer, a $10,000 limited edition Les Paul will not do you any good. Conversely, if you’re not creative, a $10,000 studio is not going to be of much use to you either. Don’t get hung up on what you see outside of yourself – gear, projects, other sound designer’s techniques and work. Focus on what you see inside of yourself. I might have a bigger recording studio than you, but you might have better ideas than me. Therefore, your work might sound far better than anything I could produce. Remember Mr. Miyaga from the Karate Kid? He told Danielson that Karate is not in his head it’s in his heart. Sound design is not in your rack, it’s inside you.
I have a tattoo on my right arm that my wife designed for me. It’s a deck of cards with the Ace of Spades sticking out from the bottom. It’s there to remind me that life is five card stud, not five card draw. You can’t ask for different cards. You have to play the cards you’re dealt. You can sit and complain about your parents, your city, and even your economic status all of your life and nothing will change. Or, you can sit up at the table and play the game with what you were dealt. But, don’t worry – you can still win a round of poker with a crappy hand as long as you play your cards right.
The whole point I’m trying to make is don’t waste your time waiting for something to come along to make you a better sound designer (school, projects, money, gear, a different city or country). Look around at what you do have and start there.
Avoid getting blinded by the flashing LEDs on that new piece of gear and save your money for the things that really matter. Remember, even though the Imperial Army had more advanced weapons, they were defeated by Ewoks using only sticks and stones.
Hans says
#2´s headline is quite misleading and even contradicting what you write in the text that follows it.
Recording hot levels on a zoom H2 will NOT sound better than lower levels on a Aaton Cantar.
Why? Because the great recorder will most likely have the better pre-amps as well and cranking up poor pre-amps on a cheap machine will give you even more noise. Ever tried the high gain setting on the H2 and you will know what I mean.
You probably meant the right thing but the the head-line doesn´t make sense.
Jed says
Thanks Ric, there are some really good advice here! Although, when you say “Always record at the hottest level possible. You can always back it down later” reminds me David Farmer’s special Field Recording 2010 that I highly recommend: https://designingsound.org/2010/09/david-farmer-special-field-recording-2010/
“Except for extreme low levels, I never had any issues with recording lower to tape. In fact, I usually record leaving plenty of room for peaks, both then & now. I can’t stand getting a recording back from someone and finding that they were riding the levels. It’s never smooth enough, so just let us take care of that on the back end. It’s incredibly difficult to correct something where the levels were ridden incorrectly […] They’d see something start to clip and back off the levels. Right there – the recording is already ruined IMO. So my approach has always been to record at a low enough level that it won’t ever clip, and don’t touch the levels during a take. If something happens to clip, I just let it ride and then back off the level for the next take. There are some decent tools nowadays to repair clipping so I’ll give that a try (again Izotope RX).” David Farmer.
Ric Viers says
Good point. Sorry for the confusion. The purpose of that tip was that getting good levels to the recorder is critical, especially if you are using a lower brand. Further, you can make a good recorder sound bad if you record with extremely low levels. This why I had an editor help with my book! ; ) In my experience, importance of gear quality goes: Recorder, then mics, then headphones. If you can’t afford a good recorder, make sure that you focus on great levels. Hope this clarifies!
Nikos Chatzigeorgiadis says
Ric I really want to thank you for this!
I have been a fan of you quite some time now. I hope I will meet and thank you in person some time.
If I ever make something really good (as I intend to), and they ask me of my favorite sound designers, you will be my first choice and thats for sure. Ben Burtt might be the father of the kind and everybody’s favorite but you man… you cut to the chase and share true tips and info that can actually make you better if you are a beginner or a pro!
Thanks again!
Ric Viers says
@Jed David Farmer is great. When I field record I never adjust levels during a take, because as he said, the take is pretty much ruined. I typically leave my levels alone unless I have to. If my levels are pretty low, I try to move closer to the sound source. If I clip, I’ll grab a safety take. I recently had some recordings some in from a recordist that were so low, the material was a loss. His reason was he didn’t want clip. Granted, his levels were excessively low. The point was intended for people to avoid reording too low.
Ric Viers says
@Nikos Thanks! But trust me, if all the great sound designers of the world worked in the same building, I would probably be the janitor! ; )
Ryan says
Hey Ric,
The Ewoks had bows and arrows, too…
Great advice. Thanks for the article!
charles maynes says
lovely article- to expand on the levels while recording issue- sometimes elevated levels do change the timbre of the sound- to record with a set amount of headroom may not always be possible. sometimes the source will be too quiet, sometimes too loud- the recordist has to deal with the tradeoffs in the moment…. but the important thing is having the record light on…
James Bretz says
Thanks Ric, Good tips there.
I especialy like the analogy with the painter and their brushes. Sound Design starts on the inside.
Ilyés József says
Hi Ric !
Thanx the good Tips & Family Guy story :)
I used to watch the Detroit Chop Shop video diary and is also very good.
Sorry my poor english…
Thanks Again !
Tom@engineaudio says
Great article Ric! There is not way to show my level of support for this concept. This conversation always works for my students. All I have to do is play them a great recording without telling them it was done on a Zoom H2 first. Then the idea sinks in a little bit more. I am going to insist that my students read this, perhaps for extra credit. :-)
Christian says
Ric – good stuff here man. I appreciate you taking the time to blog.
Rucklo says
Ric – you da man! When I grow up (closing in on 30 already… <__>) I wanna be a janitor in the building of SD’s juuust like you! :p
Nikos Chatzigeorgiadis says
Hooray for the janitors and floor managers in the SD buildings then!
Linas says
one question…is it a good start to buy a handheld recorder like zoom or tascam or similar?or should i think about mics and stuff, i want to start record my own things, but i dont know is it a really good start to begin just with a recorder?
Jim Stout says
Some of the best advice I have read in a long time. Thanks Ric.
:-)
Edwardo Santiago says
This is one of the best articles on earth. Thank you for the wake up call. I’m a fan.
Sönam Gray says
Very well spoken Ric. Great and honest specifics, I’m probably going to frame that in the studio as a reminder so don’t sue me…
Brandon says
Hey Ric,
I’m somewhat new to foley and creating sound effects. I’m using the ZoomH4 and I’m such a noob with these handheld recorders. Good thing I watched your video with the zoom. Just wanted to say thanks for all the help I got from your site and this one. I have all these wonderful Ideas for creating some cool sound effects. I also wanted to ask you for some advice on creating some sci-fi effects. Are magnets and electronics the only way to go on this one?